8.4 Persons, Humans and Brains
Updated: January 23, 2025
Summary
The video delves into the distinction between persons and animals, proposing to collapse this line to focus on the identity of physical organisms. It explores the concept of personal identity based on brain function, discussing brain transplants and the impact of split brains on personal continuity. Additionally, it reflects on the need to reinterpret traditional concepts like marriage and gender in philosophy to accommodate evolving societal norms.
Distinction Between Persons and Animals
Exploring the distinction between persons and animals and considering collapsing this distinction to focus on identity of physical organisms.
Collapse of the Distinction
Discussing the implications of collapsing the distinction between person and implications of being a person, potentially separating personhood from the physical organism.
Identity and Brain Function
Contemplating the concept of personal identity based on brain function and the possibility of identifying a person through the brain rather than the whole organism, with examples of brain transplants.
Split Brain and Personal Identity
Analyzing the scenario of split brains and its impact on personal identity, including the idea of having two separate bodies with shared memories and implications for personal continuity.
Reinterpretation of Concepts
Exploring the reinterpretation of concepts, such as marriage and gender, in philosophy to adapt to changing societal norms and understandings.
Ambiguity in Concepts
Reflecting on the ambiguity in philosophical concepts when applied to real-world scenarios and the need to adapt or invent new concepts to address evolving perspectives.
FAQ
Q: What is the potential implication of collapsing the distinction between persons and animals in terms of focusing on the identity of physical organisms?
A: The potential implication of collapsing the distinction between persons and animals is a shift towards focusing on the identity of physical organisms and blurring the lines between what constitutes personhood.
Q: How is personal identity contemplated based on brain function and what is the possibility of identifying a person through the brain?
A: Personal identity is contemplated based on brain function, suggesting the possibility of identifying a person through the brain rather than the entire organism. This opens up discussions on the role of the brain in defining personhood.
Q: Can you provide examples of brain transplants and their relevance in discussions related to personal identity?
A: Brain transplants, though currently in the realm of science fiction, serve as thought experiments to explore the boundaries of personal identity and the potential separability of the person from the physical body.
Q: What is the scenario of split brains, and how does it impact personal identity?
A: The scenario of split brains involves the separation of the two hemispheres of the brain, leading to the possibility of having two separate bodies with shared memories. This scenario challenges traditional notions of personal identity and raises questions about personal continuity.
Q: How can concepts like marriage and gender be reinterpreted in philosophy to adapt to changing societal norms and understandings?
A: Concepts like marriage and gender can be reinterpreted in philosophy to adapt to changing societal norms and understandings by acknowledging the fluidity and complexity of these constructs and the need for philosophical flexibility in addressing evolving perspectives.
Q: Why is there a need to adapt or invent new concepts in philosophy when applied to real-world scenarios?
A: The need to adapt or invent new concepts in philosophy when applied to real-world scenarios arises from the inherent ambiguity in philosophical concepts and the necessity to ensure that philosophical frameworks remain relevant and reflective of evolving societal perspectives.
Get your own AI Agent Today
Thousands of businesses worldwide are using Chaindesk Generative
AI platform.
Don't get left behind - start building your
own custom AI chatbot now!